In the prestigious Ace of Spades HQ Book Thread today, CBD (ask your mom what that means) finds an app that could seem useful:
I saw this app…somewhere, and I was immediately intrigued. My relationship with AI is on-again/off-again, so I am reserving judgement until one of you maniacs gives it a try. It certainly is a fine idea!
Take a photo of your bookshelf. In seconds, every book is catalogued, searchable, and ready to surprise you. Sounds fantastic! I have hundreds of books whose origins are unknown to me, so a list of them that is actually useful sounds wonderful.
So…what’s the catch?
Ads or a subscription, plus who knows what else they will do with your data (unlike, say, a locally hosted, self-contained collection tracking app).
Also, it might work for some libraries, but certainly not Nogglestead, where the disorganized books are double stacked on the shelves (meaning a photo of all the book shelves might only get half of the books), and some books face out blocking other books. Not to mention how much correction the “AI” will take. When I had an LLM scrape the blog’s Good Book Hunting posts for books that I’ve bought to use as test data in the Got It/Want It app, and then I spent six hours correcting the data. I would expect I’d have to do at least that much work on the larger data set on my bookshelves.
Nah, that’s all right. I’ll just enter the books into the database one at a time as I read them, and give the duplicates I pick up away (years later when I discover I’ve picked up a duplicate, often–although using my own app might make this less likely to occur).


